Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Richard Seager's avatar

Happy New Year Dubby. Not sure about that history though and whether it really matters unless Netanyahu is seeking to rally support. The history of the Mediterranean, like elsewhere, is full of tall tales, people pick out the bits of these that are suitable for them. The truth though is much harder to find but yes in the 7th and maybe 8th Centuries in the Levant a lot of Jews converted to Islam. So much so that the Romans thought that Islam was a Jewish religion. Earlier this whole area, from the Black Sea to the Red Sea (and out to Gibralta more or less) had been Greek. So the conversion to Islam had not been the first conversion in my view.

In regards to the now, the victims from October 8th have been the Palestinians which should ask questions of what happened on the day before as you have suggested. Further those around Netanyauh are making it known that the Palestinians can just be sent elsewhere, to Rwanda, to Europe to America. The Israel military has clearly been tasked to make their lives hell so as they'll agree to it. Israeli political hacks have estimated that the monetary cost can be handled mainly because Egypt (and Rwanda?) are poor. They consider it a once in a lifetime "opportunity".

Could we find allegories from 17th/18th/19th C America or Australia or New Zealand. I'm sure that we could, for example some European commentators around the late 19th C / beginning of the 20th C discussed the end of the Maori race albeit they wern't actively trying to make it happen by war but I'm sure that they were pursuing other policies to bring it about. Does this make what is happening in Palestine any better?

I believe the Neanderthals were the original (homo but not sapien) inhabitants of both Israel and Europe...

Expand full comment
The Word Herder's avatar

Good writing, and you make some excellent points. Me, I'm in favor of mixing everyone and stopping the separations that now exist in different "races"... I think there's ONE race of us bipeds: Human. But perhaps we're not sophisticated enough yet? I donut know, my lovely Dubby, but I abhor the way people treat each other when feeling one group is "superior" to another... Such a terrible history we all share regarding this kind of arrogant Fear of Other, as it were.

As for White Protestants, there's nothing in most of their spew that Jesus would have ever agreed with!!! And Jesus was a JEW, not a "Christian," and he didn't start Christianity, that was Paul and a couple others, which was then subsumed and re-directed by the Ever-Fucking Romans...

Anyway, you know I'm a collage-lover, in every sense of the word, and I know YOU and I love you, whether we agree on every tiny detail in life or not! I'm a dog, after all. I don't go by RACE, as it were, I go by SMED (sniff, sniff!).

;)

xo xo xo

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts